The September Issue by R.J.Cutler at Sheffield Doc/Fest 2009
0 comments"Since when did glamour ever equate with happiness?" - Jude Calvert-Toulmin
The internationally acclaimed Sheffield Doc/Fest kicks off again from the 4th to the 8th of November for its fifteenth year.
One thing I particularly like about this year's programme is the highlighting of docs having been produced as a result of previous Sheffield Doc/Fest Meetmarket pitches, where filmmakers meet commissioning editors. The Meetmarket is now one of the those industry must-attends for documentary filmmakers trying to get their films off the ground. A bit like a sweetshop for documentary filmmakers. Rows and rows of jars of commissioning editors. Yummy.
"Fashion is a religion. This is a bible." The fashion industry cannot be serious. Oh woops, it is. Well, it's not a great big secret that religion is responsible for mass brainwashing, war and self-delusion, not to mention unhappiness, so the poster says it all really.
All the way through viewing The September Issue online here I kept thinking that this film should be called "Portrait of a Sad Lady." Anna Wintour looks perpetually sad, grim, bored and unfulfilled. But then I reminded myself that this is not an intimate portrait of the inner life of a human being, as you will find in the documentaries of Sundance award-winning documentary filmmaker Sean McAllister for example, but a portrait of a person in a powerful career position, at work.
Anna Wintour heads a huge organisation in the most bitchy industry on earth. Of course she's got to be seen to be cold and hard. She spends her working life being scrutinised, criticised and under constant attack. Any chink in the armour and she'll bleed. I don't believe for one minute that off duty she doesn't occasionally put her feet up on the sofa and roar with laughter at something funny on the tele. And even sometimes dribble food down her chin when she's eating. She's a human being for god's sake. I would have liked to have seen more of that human being, but this wasn't the documentary for it. This, as it says on the tin, is about the production of The September Issue, not an intimate portrait of Anna Wintour, human being.
Vogue Artistic Director Grace Coddington, who does come across as a much warmer, artistic person in the documentary, at one point says to an underling, "You must demand or you will be blamed." Yeah it's dog eat dog in the Vogue offices. There's more warmth between a bunch of starving children living in the slums of Jakarta than amongst these people in this supposed glamorous industry. But since when did glamour ever equate with happiness? Anna Wintour defends herself by stating that the fashion industry gets criticised by those who feel left out of the "cool group":
"What I often see is that people are scared of fashion — because they're frightened or insecure, so they put it down. On the whole, people who say demeaning things about our world, I think it's because they feel in some way excluded or not part of the "cool group." Just because you like to put on a beautiful Carolina Herrera dress of a pair of J Brand blue jeans instead of something basic from K-Mart doesn't mean you're a dumb person. There is something about fashion that can make people very nervous."
As TatianaTheAnonymousModel points out in the best article I've read yet about The September Issue,
"It's often those who themselves are most desperate to be taken seriously who are quickest to project "insecurity" onto others."
Just what I was thinking, Tatiana. I'm not scared of fashion. I've modelled, designed and made my own clothes, am fascinated by fabrics and can spot a Matthew Williamson from the other side of the ground floor of Debenhams, as I did with my wedding dress. But the fashion industry, whose laws are decreed not only by body fascist women like Wintour but also by gay men who want every woman to look like an adolescent male, is unhealthy and leads to millions of women being uncomfortable and unhappy with their bodies. That fundamental problem is what attracts criticism fuelled not by petty teenage jealousy through wanting to run with "the cool crowd", but genuine criticism from women of all ages. Jesus, Anna, I was a stay-at-home mother of three and now I'm a granny. You don't get cooler than that, love.
Hold on, Anna's got her work head on. She doesn't really believe in a cool crowd and she isn't really a body fascist. She's just a burd who cares about her job and to do that well, has to keep the armour polished. We can all breathe a sigh of relief. She's just like all the rest of us workaholics, only with an expensive face.*
* Ouch, that sounded bitchy. Which article am I writing again? Oh yeah. The one about the fashion industry. That's OK then.
What I loved about The September Issue apart from all of it.
The editing. Just gorgeous.
The shot of the gold fringed flapper dress.
The focus pulls.
The model laughing as she ate the tarte aux framboises.
The music. Ladytron's Destroy Everything You Touch was perfect.
Bob and the jumping model.
Grace Coddington getting the public recognition she damn well deserves.
I will be on the information desk at Sheffield Doc/Fest from 8.30am until 1.30pm for the duration of the festival, wearing my signature black Kangol beret with a different coloured swansdown bobble on it every day.
Below: Trailer for The September Issue.
Sheffield Doc/Fest site
September Issue site
The Gawker - How Grace Coddington Stole The September Issue from Anna Wintour
The Huffington Post - edited transcript of conversation between Vogue Creative Director Grace Coddington and Vogue editor Jay Fielden at a New York Public Library event ("Close-Up on Grace Coddington") on October 20, 2009.
Sheffield Doc/Fest on facebook
September Issue on facebook
Pixelwitchpictures (who took the Heather/Vivienne shot) Shipley Harley Davidson Club Calendar 2010































































